header banner

Do You Want to Buy or Sell Priceless Coins or Bills? Be Aware Of These 7 Scam Red Flags

Ancient coins of the first republic.

Paolo Gagliardi / Getty Images/iStockphoto

Old coins and bills tucked in wallets, drawers, change jars, or even amidst your couch cushions could be worth hundreds or thousands of dollars beyond their face value.

But with every money-making opportunity comes scammers — it’s the other side of the coin, so to speak. Coin and bill collectors know how to spot frauds and con artists. But for the average person looking to unload their $2 bills for a couple of hundred bucks, it may not be that easy.

Fortunately, the scams to watch out for when it comes to buying or selling your old currency are similar to other scams. Bad actors in every industry leave clues. Here are some of the signs to watch out for when it comes to buying and selling your coins or bills.

Bad Reviews at the Better Business Bureau

VIDEO: Why Quarters Have Ridges 😕 (not what you think)
Zack D. Films

A good indicator of a scam artist in any industry, negative reviews or a poor rating with the Better Business Bureau is a big red flag, according to Atlanta Gold and Coin. Likewise, look at sites such as RipOffReport.com, TrustPilot.com, and even Google reviews to ascertain how trustworthy a coin dealer might be.

Not a Member of Reputable Numismatic Organizations

VIDEO: Don't get scammed! 7 red flags 🚩 of a crypto rug-pull
Game Thinking TV

Just as poor reviews are red flags, so is a lack of credentials. Atlanta Gold and Coin pointed out in a blog post that dealers who are part of the American Numismatic Association or the Professional Numismatics Guild are more likely to be reputable.

New to the Business

VIDEO: 3 Crypto Scams YOU WILL Fall For & How To Avoid
Adam Venture Crypto

To join PNG, according to Atlanta Gold and Coin, you must be in the industry for at least five years and hold numismatic assets of at least $175,000.

Ideally, seek out a dealer who’s been buying and selling coins and bank notes even longer. As in any industry, a company that’s been around for decades has maintained its business by exemplifying good ethics, fair pricing, and above-the-board customer service.

If a company is new, it could be someone just entering the market, or it could be a fly-by-night scammer looking to take advantage of people amidst the rising prices of gold and other precious metals.

Not Thoroughly Evaluating Your Coins or Bills

VIDEO: 10 eBay SCAMS You Should Know About!

If you’re trying to sell your coins or bills, be wary of a dealer who glosses over the condition, mintage, or rarity. These factors can greatly affect the value of your coin or bill and you could wind up with an offer that’s less than your collection deserves.

Will Not Present Certificates of Authenticity

VIDEO: 31 ULTRA RARE Error Bills worth A LOT of MONEY!
Old Money Prices

Likewise, if you’re purchasing coins or bills, request to see certificates of authenticity. Selling counterfeit coins, according to RareCoin.store, is one of the most common fraud tactics today. While not all rare coins or notes come with COAs, a fair number do — or are graded by numismatic organizations and placed in a protective flip or slab.

Selling for Extremely Low Prices

VIDEO: HOW To Sell Your Old Coins I think most coin collectors didn't tell you that.Coins worth money
coins of rosy

A scammer may offer their coins for well below market value. That could be because they are selling fakes. If the supposed dealer sells a counterfeit coin for half the price of what an original, authentic version would go for, the dealer can still make a profit, and you’ll be left with a fake that you can’t re-sell.

High Pressure Sales

VIDEO: This entire coin collection is 100% FAKE! How to identify counterfeits

A dealer that puts unnecessary pressure on you to make a purchase or a sale may have something to hide. They want to finalize the deal before you catch on to their dishonesty.

How To Protect Yourself

Pawn Stars

To avoid these scenarios, do your own independent research regarding the coins or bank notes you plan to sell, investigate the companies thoroughly, and don’t rush into any sales or purchases. As with most things in personal finance, if an offer for your rare coin or bill seems too good to be true, it probably is.

More From GOBankingRates

  • Suze Orman: 3 Things You Must Do If You Receive an Inheritance
  • How To Get Free Money: 13 Proven Ways
  • 3 Things You Must Do When Your Savings Reach $50,000
  • 10 Smartest Ways to Make Your Money Work for You, According to Experts


Article information

Author: James Martinez

Last Updated: 1699294803

Views: 807

Rating: 4.8 / 5 (30 voted)

Reviews: 82% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: James Martinez

Birthday: 1989-08-31

Address: 9504 Carlos Parkways, North Thomas, MA 82739

Phone: +3550300143239011

Job: Video Game Designer

Hobby: Robotics, Cross-Stitching, Board Games, Singing, Photography, Calligraphy, Ice Skating

Introduction: My name is James Martinez, I am a accessible, irreplaceable, lively, exquisite, skilled, dazzling, audacious person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.